Parallel BGL Parallel BGL Process Groups

# Parallel BGL Process Groups

Contents

- Introduction
- Communication model
  - Distributed data structures
  - Asynchronous receives
  - Out-of-band messaging
- Reference
  - Process group constructors
  - Triggers
  - Helper operations
  - Process query
  - Message transmission
  - Synchronization
  - Out-of-band communication

# Introduction

Process groups are an abstraction of a set of communicating processes that coordinate to solve the same problem. Process groups contain facilities for identifying the processes within that group, sending and receiving messages between the processes in that group, and performing collective communications involving all processes in the group simultaneously.

# Communication model

Process groups are based on an extended version of the Bulk Synchronous Parallel (BSP) model of computation. Parallel computations in the BSP model are organized into supersteps, each of which consists of a computation phase followed by a communication phase. During the computation phase, all processes in the process group work exclusively on local data, and there is no inter-process communication. During the communication phase, all of the processes exchange message with each other. Messages sent in the communication phase of a superstep will be received in the next superstep.

The boundary between supersteps in the Parallel BGL corresponds to the `synchronize` operation. Whenever a process has completed its local computation phase and sent all of the messages required for that superstep, it invokes the `synchronize` operation on the process group. Once all processes in the process group have entered `synchronize`, they exchange messages and then continue with the next superstep.

The Parallel BGL loosens the BSP model significantly, to provide a more natural programming model that also provides some performance benefits over the strict BSP model. The primary extension is the ability to receive messages sent within the same superstep "asynchronously", either to free up message buffers or to respond to an immediate request for information. For particularly unstructured computations, the ability to send a message and get an immediate reply can simplify many computations that would otherwise need to be split into two separate supersteps. Additionally, the Parallel BGL augments the BSP model with support for multiple distributed data structures, each of which are provided with a different communication space but whose messages will all be synchronized concurrently.

## Distributed data structures

A typical computation with the Parallel BGL involves several distributed data structures working in concern. For example, a simple breadth-first search involves the distributed graph data structure containing the graph itself, a distributed queue that manages the traversal through the graph, and a distributed property map that tracks which vertices have already been visited as part of the search.

The Parallel BGL manages these distributed data structures by allowing each of the data structures to attach themselves to the process group itself. When a distributed data structure attaches to the process group, it receives its own copy of the process group that allows the distributed data structure to communicate without colliding with the communications from other distributed data structures. When the process group is synchronized, all of the distributed data structures attached to that process group are automatically synchronized, so that all of the distributed data structures in a computation remain synchronized.

A distributed data structure attaches itself to the process group by creating a copy of the process group and passing an `attach_distributed_object` flag to the process group constructor. So long as this copy of the process group persists, the distributed data structure is attached the process group. For this reason, most distributed data structures keep a copy of the process group as member data, constructing the member with `attach_distributed_object`, e.g.,

    template<typename ProcessGroup>
    struct distributed_data_structure
    {
      explicit distributed_data_structure(const ProcessGroup& pg)
        : process_group(pg, boost::parallel::attach_distributed_object())
      { }

    private:
      ProcessGroup process_group;
    };

## Asynchronous receives

Distributed data structures in the Parallel BGL can "asynchronously" receive and process messages before the end of a BSP superstep. Messages can be received any time that a process is inside the process group operations, and the scheduling of message receives is entirely managed by the process group.

Distributed data structures receive messages through "triggers". Triggers are function objects responsible for processing a received message. Each trigger is registered with the `trigger` method of the process group using a specific message tag (an integer) and the type of data that is expected to be contained within that message. Whenever a message with that tag becomes available, the progress group will call the trigger with the source of the message, the message tag, the data contained in the message, and the "context" of the message.

The majority of triggers have no return value, although it is common that the triggers send messages back to the source process. In certain cases where the trigger's purpose is to immediately reply with a value, the trigger should be registered with the `trigger_with_reply` method and should return the value that will be sent back to the caller. The `trigger_with_reply` facility is only useful in conjunction with out-of-band messaging, discussed next.

## Out-of-band messaging

The majority of messages sent by the Parallel BGL are sent through the normal send operations, to be received in the next superstep or, in some cases, received "early" by a trigger. These messages are not time-sensitive, so they will be delivered whenever the process group processes them.

Some messages, however, require immediate responses. For example, if a process needs to determine the current value associated with a vertex owned by another process, the first process must send a request to the second process and block while waiting for a response. For such messages, the Parallel BGL's process groups provide an out-of-band messaging mechanism. Out-of-band messages are transmitted immediately, with a much higher priority than other messages. The sending of out-of-band messages can be coupled with a receive operation that waits until the remote process has received the message and sent its reply. For example, in the following code the process sends a message containing the string `name` to process `owner` with tag `msg_get_descriptor_by_name` via an out-of-band message. The receiver of that message will immediately deliver the message via a trigger, that returns the resulting value--a `vertex_descriptor`--that will be passed back to the process that initiated the communication. The full communication happens immediately, within the current superstep.

    std::string name;
    vertex_descriptor descriptor;
    send_oob_with_reply(process_group, owner, msg_get_descriptor_by_name,
                        name, descriptor);

# Reference

The Parallel BGL process groups specify an interface that can be implemented by various communication subsystems. In this reference section, we use the placeholder type `ProcessGroup` to stand in for the various process group implementations that exist. There is only one implementation of the process group interface at this time:

> - MPI BSP process group

    enum trigger_receive_context {
      trc_none,
      trc_in_synchronization,
      trc_early_receive,
      trc_out_of_band
    };

    class ProcessGroup
    {
      // Process group constructors
      ProcessGroup();
      ProcessGroup(const ProcessGroup&, boost::parallel::attach_distributed_object);

      // Triggers
      template<typename Type, typename Handler>
        void trigger(int tag, const Handler& handler);

      template<typename Type, typename Handler>
        void trigger_with_reply(int tag, const Handler& handler);

      trigger_receive_context trigger_context() const;

      // Helper operations
      void poll();
      ProcessGroup base() const;
    };

    // Process query
    int process_id(const ProcessGroup&);
    int num_processes(const ProcessGroup&);

    // Message transmission
    template<typename T>
      void send(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int tag, const T& value);

    template<typename T>
      void receive(const ProcessGroup& pg, int source, int tag, T& value);

    optional<std::pair<int, int> > probe(const ProcessGroup& pg);

    // Synchronization
    void synchronize(const ProcessGroup& pg);

    // Out-of-band communication
    template<typename T>
      void send_oob(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int tag, const T& value);

    template<typename T, typename U>
      void
      send_oob_with_reply(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int
                          tag, const T& send_value, U& receive_value);

    template<typename T>
      void receive_oob(const ProcessGroup& pg, int source, int tag, T& value);

## Process group constructors

    ProcessGroup();

Constructs a new process group with a different communication space from any other process group.

    ProcessGroup(const ProcessGroup& pg, boost::parallel::attach_distributed_object);

Attaches a new distributed data structure to the process group `pg`. The resulting process group can be used for communication within that new distributed data structure. When the newly-constructed process group is eventually destroyed, the distributed data structure is detached from the process group.

## Triggers

    template<typename Type, typename Handler>
      void trigger(int tag, const Handler& handler);

Registers a trigger with the given process group. The trigger will watch for messages with the given `tag`. When such a message is available, it will be received into a value of type `Type`, and the function object `handler` will be invoked with four parameters:

source
  The rank of the source process (an `int`)
tag
  The tag used to send the message (also an `int`)
data:
  The data transmitted with the message. The data will have the type specified when the trigger was registered.
context:
  The context in which the trigger is executed. This will be a value of type `trigger_receive_context`, which stages whether the trigger is being executed during synchronization, asynchronously in response to an "early" receive (often to free up communication buffers), or in response to an "out-of-band" message.

Triggers can only be registered by process groups that result from attaching a distributed data structure. A trigger can be invoked in response to either a normal send operation or an out-of-band send operation. There is also a simple trigger interface for defining triggers in common cases.

    template<typename Type, typename Handler>
      void trigger_with_reply(int tag, const Handler& handler);

Like the `trigger` method, registers a trigger with the given process group. The trigger will watch for messages with the given `tag`. When such a message is available, it will be received into a value of type `Type` and `handler` will be invoked, just as with a normal trigger. However, a trigger registered with `trigger_with_reply` must return a value, which will be immediately sent back to the process that initiated the send resulting in this trigger. Thus, `trigger_with_reply` should only be used for messages that need immediate responses. These triggers can only be invoked via the out-of-band sends that wait for the reply, via `send_oob_with_reply`. There is also a simple trigger interface for defining triggers in common cases.

    trigger_receive_context trigger_context() const;

Retrieves the current context of the process group with respect to the invocation of triggers. When `trc_none`, the process group is not currently invoking any triggers. Otherwise, this value describes in what context the currently executing trigger is being invoked.

## Helper operations

    void poll();

Permits the process group to receive any incomining messages, processing them via triggers. If you have a long-running computation that does not invoke any of the process group's communication routines, you should call `poll` occasionally to along incoming messages to be processed.

    ProcessGroup base() const;

Retrieves the "base" process group for this process group, which is a copy of the underlying process group that does not reference any specific distributed data structure.

## Process query

    int process_id(const ProcessGroup& pg);

Retrieves the ID (or "rank") of the calling process within the process group. Process IDs are values in the range [0, `num_processes(pg)`) that uniquely identify the process. Process IDs can be used to initiate communication with another process.

    int num_processes(const ProcessGroup& pg);

Returns the number of processes within the process group.

## Message transmission

    template<typename T>
      void send(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int tag, const T& value);

Sends a message with the given `tag` and carrying the given `value` to the process with ID `dest` in the given process group. All message sends are non-blocking, meaning that this send operation will not block while waiting for the communication to complete. There is no guarantee when the message will be received, except that it will become available to the destination process by the end of the superstep, in the collective call to `synchronize`.

Any type of value can be transmitted via `send`, so long as it provides the appropriate functionality to be serialized with the Boost.Serialization library.

    template<typename T>
      void receive(const ProcessGroup& pg, int source, int tag, T& value);

Receives a message with the given `tag` sent from the process `source`, updating `value` with the payload of the message. This receive operation can only receive messages sent within the previous superstep via the `send` operation. If no such message is available at the time `receive` is called, the program is ill-formed.

    optional<std::pair<int, int> > probe(const ProcessGroup& pg);

Determines whether a message is available. The probe operation checks for any messages that were sent in the previous superstep but have not yet been received. If such a message exists, `probe` returns a (source, tag) pair describing the message. Otherwise, `probe` will return an empty `boost::optional`.

A typical use of `probe` is to continually probe for messages at the beginning of the superstep, receiving and processing those messages until no messages remain.

## Synchronization

    void synchronize(const ProcessGroup& pg);

The `synchronize` function is a collective operation that must be invoked by all of the processes within the process group. A call to `synchronize` marks the end of a superstep in the parallel computation. All messages sent before the end of the superstep will be received into message buffers, and can be processed by the program in the next superstep. None of the processes will leave the `synchronize` function until all of the processes have entered the function and exchanged messages, so that all processes are always on the same superstep.

## Out-of-band communication

    template<typename T>
      void send_oob(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int tag, const T& value);

Sends and out-of-band message. This out-of-band send operation acts like the normal `send` operation, except that out-of-band messages are delivered immediately through a high-priority channel.

    template<typename T, typename U>
      void
      send_oob_with_reply(const ProcessGroup& pg, int dest, int
                          tag, const T& send_value, U& receive_value);

Sends an out-of-band message and waits for a reply. The `send_oob_with_reply` function can only be invoked with message tags that correspond to triggers registered with `trigger_with_reply`. This operation will send the message immediately (through the high-priority, out-of-band channel), then wait until the remote process sends a reply. The data from the reply is stored into `receive_value`.

    template<typename T>
      void receive_oob(const ProcessGroup& pg, int source, int tag, T& value);

Receives an out-of-band message with the given `source` and `tag`. As with the normal `receive` operation, it is an error to call `receive_oob` if no message matching the source and tag is available. This routine is used only rarely; for most circumstances, use `send_oob_with_reply` to perform an immediate send with a reply.

Copyright (C) 2007 Douglas Gregor

Copyright (C) 2007 Matthias Troyer